10-31-2005, 10:31 PM
Ravi,
<!--QuoteBegin-->QUOTE<!--QuoteEBegin-->Who is Airavat Singh? Are he and Mr Guleria the same.?
<!--QuoteEnd--><!--QuoteEEnd-->
Let me state that I don't know either Airavat Singh or Mr Guleria. But I've read some published works of Airavat Singh at other forums. If I'm not mistaken he's an accomplished author of several books pertaining on history and strategic security matters.
Also, let me state that my knowledge of both Jat and Rajput history is extremely limited.
<!--QuoteBegin-->QUOTE<!--QuoteEBegin-->Is Mr Airavat Singh available?<!--QuoteEnd--><!--QuoteEEnd-->
On this forum (or any other internet forum or yahoogroups) we read/review/critique works of several authors - some members here, some not, some alive, some dead. Doesn't stop us from commenting on their work and should stop you too. And I doubt if you can produce Mr. Kokhar here to defend his work either.
On forums when one makes a particular case against a particular view point, it helps if one can point out as to why the author is wrong with your own supporting theory which could be backed by a author/work of your choice. As indicated by another moderator earlier, we'd like the thread to be focused on Jat History with very limited focus on authors or individuals in questions (unless you can make a case that the person in question either Mr.Kohkar or Mr. Singh has an agenda which others don't know about).
<!--QuoteBegin-->QUOTE<!--QuoteEBegin-->Who is Airavat Singh? Are he and Mr Guleria the same.?
<!--QuoteEnd--><!--QuoteEEnd-->
Let me state that I don't know either Airavat Singh or Mr Guleria. But I've read some published works of Airavat Singh at other forums. If I'm not mistaken he's an accomplished author of several books pertaining on history and strategic security matters.
Also, let me state that my knowledge of both Jat and Rajput history is extremely limited.
<!--QuoteBegin-->QUOTE<!--QuoteEBegin-->Is Mr Airavat Singh available?<!--QuoteEnd--><!--QuoteEEnd-->
On this forum (or any other internet forum or yahoogroups) we read/review/critique works of several authors - some members here, some not, some alive, some dead. Doesn't stop us from commenting on their work and should stop you too. And I doubt if you can produce Mr. Kokhar here to defend his work either.
On forums when one makes a particular case against a particular view point, it helps if one can point out as to why the author is wrong with your own supporting theory which could be backed by a author/work of your choice. As indicated by another moderator earlier, we'd like the thread to be focused on Jat History with very limited focus on authors or individuals in questions (unless you can make a case that the person in question either Mr.Kohkar or Mr. Singh has an agenda which others don't know about).