01-29-2006, 03:11 AM
http://krishworld.com/politics/?page_id=22
Hindutva Debunked
I am going to debunk the claims of hindu fundamentalist groups like BJP, RSS, VHP etc. one by one. Under this series, I will debunk one claim after another. In my opinion, the hindutva concept should be wiped out from the planet. I am against all religious conservatives. It is my strong belief that
Conservatism â> Fundamentalism â> Terrorism
<b>
Since I am born in the hindu religion (donât consider myself an Hindu under the current version of Hinduism) and fundamentalism is a recent concept to hindu religion, I am going to take the fight with them. I am going to debunk all their false claims one by one.</b>
Claim #1:
The rate at which Hindus are getting converted to christianity and islam, they will become minority one day.
Truth:
This is not true. If you take the census data from 1961 to 2001, the percentage of hindus in India has remainined more or less the same. The miniscule dip is very normal. it may be due to the fact that educated hindu family donât want to have 10 kids like previous generations. Also it is difficult to bring up 10s of kids in the current economic conditions. So many hindus have cut down on the number of siblings. This could have contributed to the miniscule dip. Also every religion will have their population go up and down. This miniscule dip is not due to conversions but due to factors like families realizing the stupidity of having many siblings, improvement in the economic conditions of many lower middle class families (poverty is a good breeding ground, remember), etc. Christians have remained almost the same and there is a miniscule increase in muslim population. The fact that Christian population has remained more or less the same proves that the conversion is not reducing the hindu population. Also the miniscule increase in the muslim population can be attributed to the fact that big chunk of muslim population lives under poverty and poverty is a good breeding ground. This is so miniscule that it cannot kill hinduism. Also if you take the census from 1871 and compare with 2001, there is an almost 8-10% increase in the hindu population. This also goes against the claim of hindutva bogeymen that hindu population is shrinking.
I call upon educated people to come out of their brainwash and look at the statistics to understand that the âHindutva Claimâ is bogus.
Sources:
* http://www.censusindia.net/religiondata/statement.pdf - This gives the census by religion from 1961 to 2001.
* This is one of the rare British Era Document which gives the population by religion in 1871-72. .
Claim #2:
The Hindu population has reduced in many states where they were majority and they are pushed to minority status.
Truth:
This is not true. In all states and Unition Terrirories (except for Lakshwadeep, Mizoram and Meghalaya where Hindus were minority from day 1), Hindus are far ahead of their next nearest religion. There is no way this claim can be true.
Source:
http://www.censusindia.net/cendat/datatable23.html - Clearly shows the percentage of population by religion.
http://krishworld.com/politics/?page_id=41
Hindutva Hall of Shame
In this page, I am going to list the links in the news media about the shameful acts of Hindutva gang. This is not a comprehensive list of shameful events. This is just a list I have started acquiring in the past few months. This doesnât include many of the past incidents. This page will be updated as and when I come across shameful incidents. Please bookmark this page and visit again. There is a chance that Hindu extremists might take me on for the links showcasing their extremist agenda. If something like that happens, you know who is responsible for this :-) . I am just hoping that Hindu extremists give up violence some day and enter what is known as civilized society.
1. Muslim weds Hindu, WHP calls for bandh
2. This is what happened when gujarat burned
3. Distribution of 75,000 Trishuls by Hindutva forces
4. Muslim tea vendor was thrown out of coach in Godhra
5. Adivasis angry at RSSâs forced conversion plans
6. Sanghâs Dandia song: no Muslims, please
7. Sanghâs new Kumbh to take Hindutva offensive to the Dangs
8. Israeli coupleâs kiss at Pushkar raises hackles
9. BJP defends Sania Mirzaâs dress (Read this and compare with other acts of Hindutva groups to understand their hypocrisy).
10. Lotus in wrong place, feels EC
11. Is Narendra Modi about to bar love marriages?
12. Now Parivar backs college swap
13. To âprotectâ Hindu girls, BJP govt orders 2 colleges to swap buildings
14. Avoid reveling clothes, avoid rape - Shiv Sena
15. In 2004, the state of Gujarat was criticized for including anti-Gandhi passages in its mandated school history textbooks.
16. Weâll repeat our Gujarat experiment - Ashok Singhal
17. Hindu extremist attacks on Indian filmmaker Deepa Mehta
18. Bajrang Dal ransacked M F Husainâs Mumbai apartment
19. Hindu activists storm Bombay Cinemas
20. Hindu leader says lesbian film should be about Moslem family
21. Maratha activists vandalise Bhandarkar Institute
22. Gujarat riots
2000 people killed in Gujarat, mostly muslims
2002 Gujarat violence
45 accused in riot murder walk free. Accused in burning of couple include BJP, RSS and VHP leaders
Riot-accused MLA at large, DIG moved. MLA Chaudhary shot at 2 Muslim youths, mob killed them: FIR
Governor in the time of riots Bhandari slams Modi
Forensic report disputes Godhra fire theory
23. Shiv Sena men go on the rampage
24. Anti-Valentineâs Day activists erupt in India
25. Sena threatens to disrupt Valentineâs Day celebrations
26. Shiv Sena renames Valentineâs Day as âProstitution Dayâ
27. Trishul distributed by VHP
28. 5 RSS men arrested for attack on American Missionary
29. Priest seriously injured in attack against Catholic Church
30. Australia-born missionary, children, burnt alive in Orissa
31. Father Aruldoss, was killed by suspected Hindu extremists in a remote village
32. The Srikrishna Commission Report, released at long last, underlines the Shiv Senaâs malevolent role in the communal riots in Mumbai in December 1992-January 1993, and points to the contribution of the BJP in the build-up to the violence.
33. Acharya Dharmendra was quoted in the Times of India as having said, âAlthough the local Hindu residents did ask me to hold the crowds from burning Muslim homes I would have never stopped them. This is the only way in which Ayodhya could become like the Vatican.â
34. Tearing down the Babri Masjid
35. Assassination of Mahatma Gandhi
Hindutva Debunked
I am going to debunk the claims of hindu fundamentalist groups like BJP, RSS, VHP etc. one by one. Under this series, I will debunk one claim after another. In my opinion, the hindutva concept should be wiped out from the planet. I am against all religious conservatives. It is my strong belief that
Conservatism â> Fundamentalism â> Terrorism
<b>
Since I am born in the hindu religion (donât consider myself an Hindu under the current version of Hinduism) and fundamentalism is a recent concept to hindu religion, I am going to take the fight with them. I am going to debunk all their false claims one by one.</b>
Claim #1:
The rate at which Hindus are getting converted to christianity and islam, they will become minority one day.
Truth:
This is not true. If you take the census data from 1961 to 2001, the percentage of hindus in India has remainined more or less the same. The miniscule dip is very normal. it may be due to the fact that educated hindu family donât want to have 10 kids like previous generations. Also it is difficult to bring up 10s of kids in the current economic conditions. So many hindus have cut down on the number of siblings. This could have contributed to the miniscule dip. Also every religion will have their population go up and down. This miniscule dip is not due to conversions but due to factors like families realizing the stupidity of having many siblings, improvement in the economic conditions of many lower middle class families (poverty is a good breeding ground, remember), etc. Christians have remained almost the same and there is a miniscule increase in muslim population. The fact that Christian population has remained more or less the same proves that the conversion is not reducing the hindu population. Also the miniscule increase in the muslim population can be attributed to the fact that big chunk of muslim population lives under poverty and poverty is a good breeding ground. This is so miniscule that it cannot kill hinduism. Also if you take the census from 1871 and compare with 2001, there is an almost 8-10% increase in the hindu population. This also goes against the claim of hindutva bogeymen that hindu population is shrinking.
I call upon educated people to come out of their brainwash and look at the statistics to understand that the âHindutva Claimâ is bogus.
Sources:
* http://www.censusindia.net/religiondata/statement.pdf - This gives the census by religion from 1961 to 2001.
* This is one of the rare British Era Document which gives the population by religion in 1871-72. .
Claim #2:
The Hindu population has reduced in many states where they were majority and they are pushed to minority status.
Truth:
This is not true. In all states and Unition Terrirories (except for Lakshwadeep, Mizoram and Meghalaya where Hindus were minority from day 1), Hindus are far ahead of their next nearest religion. There is no way this claim can be true.
Source:
http://www.censusindia.net/cendat/datatable23.html - Clearly shows the percentage of population by religion.
http://krishworld.com/politics/?page_id=41
Hindutva Hall of Shame
In this page, I am going to list the links in the news media about the shameful acts of Hindutva gang. This is not a comprehensive list of shameful events. This is just a list I have started acquiring in the past few months. This doesnât include many of the past incidents. This page will be updated as and when I come across shameful incidents. Please bookmark this page and visit again. There is a chance that Hindu extremists might take me on for the links showcasing their extremist agenda. If something like that happens, you know who is responsible for this :-) . I am just hoping that Hindu extremists give up violence some day and enter what is known as civilized society.
1. Muslim weds Hindu, WHP calls for bandh
2. This is what happened when gujarat burned
3. Distribution of 75,000 Trishuls by Hindutva forces
4. Muslim tea vendor was thrown out of coach in Godhra
5. Adivasis angry at RSSâs forced conversion plans
6. Sanghâs Dandia song: no Muslims, please
7. Sanghâs new Kumbh to take Hindutva offensive to the Dangs
8. Israeli coupleâs kiss at Pushkar raises hackles
9. BJP defends Sania Mirzaâs dress (Read this and compare with other acts of Hindutva groups to understand their hypocrisy).
10. Lotus in wrong place, feels EC
11. Is Narendra Modi about to bar love marriages?
12. Now Parivar backs college swap
13. To âprotectâ Hindu girls, BJP govt orders 2 colleges to swap buildings
14. Avoid reveling clothes, avoid rape - Shiv Sena
15. In 2004, the state of Gujarat was criticized for including anti-Gandhi passages in its mandated school history textbooks.
16. Weâll repeat our Gujarat experiment - Ashok Singhal
17. Hindu extremist attacks on Indian filmmaker Deepa Mehta
18. Bajrang Dal ransacked M F Husainâs Mumbai apartment
19. Hindu activists storm Bombay Cinemas
20. Hindu leader says lesbian film should be about Moslem family
21. Maratha activists vandalise Bhandarkar Institute
22. Gujarat riots
2000 people killed in Gujarat, mostly muslims
2002 Gujarat violence
45 accused in riot murder walk free. Accused in burning of couple include BJP, RSS and VHP leaders
Riot-accused MLA at large, DIG moved. MLA Chaudhary shot at 2 Muslim youths, mob killed them: FIR
Governor in the time of riots Bhandari slams Modi
Forensic report disputes Godhra fire theory
23. Shiv Sena men go on the rampage
24. Anti-Valentineâs Day activists erupt in India
25. Sena threatens to disrupt Valentineâs Day celebrations
26. Shiv Sena renames Valentineâs Day as âProstitution Dayâ
27. Trishul distributed by VHP
28. 5 RSS men arrested for attack on American Missionary
29. Priest seriously injured in attack against Catholic Church
30. Australia-born missionary, children, burnt alive in Orissa
31. Father Aruldoss, was killed by suspected Hindu extremists in a remote village
32. The Srikrishna Commission Report, released at long last, underlines the Shiv Senaâs malevolent role in the communal riots in Mumbai in December 1992-January 1993, and points to the contribution of the BJP in the build-up to the violence.
33. Acharya Dharmendra was quoted in the Times of India as having said, âAlthough the local Hindu residents did ask me to hold the crowds from burning Muslim homes I would have never stopped them. This is the only way in which Ayodhya could become like the Vatican.â
34. Tearing down the Babri Masjid
35. Assassination of Mahatma Gandhi