07-27-2006, 02:51 AM
ok this was the thread i was calling for from day one when i asked for the "grand unified theory" in the original AIT thread.
tons of articles and posts have been made in the original thread trashing the AIT - i hope we use this thread not to trash the AIT - cos thats already been done, but to come up with a comprehensive alternative theory, that would answer all doubts. For remember, we will have managed to consign AIT to flames only when our counter theory can answer ALL questions (the same holds true for theories of physics or other subjects - the new theory has to better the old theory and answer questions the old one could not).
First question - i just want an objective answer.
If all people in india are of the same ethnicity and no aryan-tribal-dravidian divide exists, then how come we have 3 completely different families of languages produced by the same people. only rational answers solicited, no polemic replies and personal opinions.
tons of articles and posts have been made in the original thread trashing the AIT - i hope we use this thread not to trash the AIT - cos thats already been done, but to come up with a comprehensive alternative theory, that would answer all doubts. For remember, we will have managed to consign AIT to flames only when our counter theory can answer ALL questions (the same holds true for theories of physics or other subjects - the new theory has to better the old theory and answer questions the old one could not).
First question - i just want an objective answer.
If all people in india are of the same ethnicity and no aryan-tribal-dravidian divide exists, then how come we have 3 completely different families of languages produced by the same people. only rational answers solicited, no polemic replies and personal opinions.