05-14-2007, 11:02 PM
Book Review from Pioneer, 13 May 2007
<!--QuoteBegin-->QUOTE<!--QuoteEBegin--><b>Gestures of greatness </b>
Kamath brings out several lesser known stories of Gandhi's spiritual journey from the plague-infested Indian ghetto in Johannesburg to Birla House where he was shot dead, writes Lata Jagtiani
Type "Books on Mahatma Gandhi" on an Internet search engine and the response throws up no less than 1,500,000 sites! It's anybody's guess how many books there might be on offer at each site. Does the world need yet another book on a subject? Surprising as this might sound, the answer is yes. The book, <b>Gandhi: A Spiritual Journey, by MV Kamath</b>, might well occupy pride of place on my bookcase for a long time to come. While the book cover, the paper quality, the friendly font, the price and the presentation are all attractive, the selection of Gandhi's own writings on the subject of spirituality is indeed a treasure.
MV Kamath's simple style of expression demystifies the colossus that was Gandhi and brings him across as a flesh-and-blood human being, attempting to go beyond the flesh and its desires.
<b>Kamath's study is in a tone that is neither obsequious nor harsh. He delivers his blows with gentleness and his appreciation with restraint.</b> His study is made all the more significant as he saw history unfold right before his eyes. In fact, as a young newspaper reporter, Kamath was present in the courtroom to cover the trial of Nathuram Godse and heard both sides present their case.
This book explores, through various excerpts and quotes, how Gandhi's spirituality lay at the base of his every thought, word and deed. Kamath observes, "It is a validation of Gandhi's philosophy that across the world social activists and leaders have chosen to follow his principle of militant non-violence. Martin Luther King Jr was greatly influenced by Gandhi's ideology of non-violent social protest. The Dalai Lama has acknowledged the inspiration he has received from Gandhi's teachings. Nelson Mandela and Aung San Suu Kyi have fought oppressive regimes drawing upon Gandhi's legacy."
On the issue of spirituality versus sexuality, Kamath cannot fathom why Gandhi needed to go to such extremes. "Can spiritualism be attained through a total separation of woman from man? Our gods have their consorts and even many of our saints and prophets were married or had women disciples. There is no reason why that should be considered a sin or an impediment to spiritualism. But Gandhi apparently had his qualms, which distract from his committed desire for spiritualism."
Kamath further reveals Gandhi's relationship with Saraladevi Chaudharani, a married woman whom he wanted as his "spiritual wife" and who paid the price of going with Gandhi. Later, she admitted, "(I) had put in one pan all the joys and pleasures of this world, and in the other Bapu and his laws and committed the folly of choosing the latter."
Gandhi's spirituality left no room for untouchability. Kamath writes that Gandhi was "so strongly against untouchability that he said that if untouchability lives, Hinduism must die and that he would far rather that Hinduism died than that untouchability lived. He did not believe in caste. As he saw it, caste had nothing to do with religion... his understanding of god and untouchability sometimes went to unacceptable lengths.
When there was a terrible earthquake in Bihar, Gandhi made a statement that even elicited a strong censure from Rabindranath Tagore. Gandhi said, "Visitations like droughts, floods, earthquakes, and the like, though they seem to have only physical origins, are, for me, somehow connected with man's morals. Therefore, I instinctively felt that the earthquake was a visitation for the sin of untouchability."
Having said that, Gandhi "was transparency personified". While spirituality underpinned his every activity, he was rational first; "every ideology had to submit to the acid test of reason before being accepted".
How did Gandhi become spiritual, what were the influences in his life that shaped him and made him the colossus he later was to become? <b>One learns that his early influences were Shravana as a devoted son, Harishchandra as the ideal truthful human being. Kamath reveals, "Every fresh reading of their stories moved him to tears." Later Ruskin's Unto This Last and Leo Tolstoy all came to influence his mind. Then came the maid Rambha who instilled in young Gandhi the faith in the "Ramanama" (Rama's name) to ward off his fear of ghosts. Gandhi wrote, "The good seed sown in childhood was not sown in vain. I think it is due to the seed sown by that good woman Rambha that today Ramanama is an infallible remedy for me."</b>
As he grew up, Gandhi cultivated a distaste for conversion. He wrote, "Suppose a Christian came to me and said he was captivated by reading the Bhagavat and so wanted to declare himself a Hindu, I should say to him, 'No, what the Bhagavat offers, the Bible also offers. You have not made the attempt to find out. Make the attempt and be a good Christian'." To him, religion meant, "adhering to values, not to a brand name".
Kamath shares with us a story that brings out Gandhi's spiritual depth right from the time he was in Johannesburg and plague had broken out in the Indian ghetto. Then, the sick and dying were taken to a quarantined building where a heroic English nurse was tending to them. "One evening, at the height of the epidemic, she saw a small figure standing at the door." Get out, this is plague," shouted the nurse. But the man standing there was Gandhi whom the nurse recognised as a leader of the Indian community. He was not about to leave. He told the nurse, "It's alright; I've come to help you." And he went straight to the sick. One man was literally covered with vermin and the nurse again shouted a warning. She told Gandhi, "Leave him." But Gandhi would not. He merely told the nurse, "He is my brother." And he stayed all night long until relief came.
Finally, one <b>would have liked the English translation of the prayer, "Vaisnava jana to tene kahiye"</b>, printed on the back cover of the book followed by a note sharing with the non-Hindi reading reader what the prayer signified for Gandhi.
<!--QuoteEnd--><!--QuoteEEnd-->
Can our members provide the original and the translation please?
<!--QuoteBegin-->QUOTE<!--QuoteEBegin--><b>Gestures of greatness </b>
Kamath brings out several lesser known stories of Gandhi's spiritual journey from the plague-infested Indian ghetto in Johannesburg to Birla House where he was shot dead, writes Lata Jagtiani
Type "Books on Mahatma Gandhi" on an Internet search engine and the response throws up no less than 1,500,000 sites! It's anybody's guess how many books there might be on offer at each site. Does the world need yet another book on a subject? Surprising as this might sound, the answer is yes. The book, <b>Gandhi: A Spiritual Journey, by MV Kamath</b>, might well occupy pride of place on my bookcase for a long time to come. While the book cover, the paper quality, the friendly font, the price and the presentation are all attractive, the selection of Gandhi's own writings on the subject of spirituality is indeed a treasure.
MV Kamath's simple style of expression demystifies the colossus that was Gandhi and brings him across as a flesh-and-blood human being, attempting to go beyond the flesh and its desires.
<b>Kamath's study is in a tone that is neither obsequious nor harsh. He delivers his blows with gentleness and his appreciation with restraint.</b> His study is made all the more significant as he saw history unfold right before his eyes. In fact, as a young newspaper reporter, Kamath was present in the courtroom to cover the trial of Nathuram Godse and heard both sides present their case.
This book explores, through various excerpts and quotes, how Gandhi's spirituality lay at the base of his every thought, word and deed. Kamath observes, "It is a validation of Gandhi's philosophy that across the world social activists and leaders have chosen to follow his principle of militant non-violence. Martin Luther King Jr was greatly influenced by Gandhi's ideology of non-violent social protest. The Dalai Lama has acknowledged the inspiration he has received from Gandhi's teachings. Nelson Mandela and Aung San Suu Kyi have fought oppressive regimes drawing upon Gandhi's legacy."
On the issue of spirituality versus sexuality, Kamath cannot fathom why Gandhi needed to go to such extremes. "Can spiritualism be attained through a total separation of woman from man? Our gods have their consorts and even many of our saints and prophets were married or had women disciples. There is no reason why that should be considered a sin or an impediment to spiritualism. But Gandhi apparently had his qualms, which distract from his committed desire for spiritualism."
Kamath further reveals Gandhi's relationship with Saraladevi Chaudharani, a married woman whom he wanted as his "spiritual wife" and who paid the price of going with Gandhi. Later, she admitted, "(I) had put in one pan all the joys and pleasures of this world, and in the other Bapu and his laws and committed the folly of choosing the latter."
Gandhi's spirituality left no room for untouchability. Kamath writes that Gandhi was "so strongly against untouchability that he said that if untouchability lives, Hinduism must die and that he would far rather that Hinduism died than that untouchability lived. He did not believe in caste. As he saw it, caste had nothing to do with religion... his understanding of god and untouchability sometimes went to unacceptable lengths.
When there was a terrible earthquake in Bihar, Gandhi made a statement that even elicited a strong censure from Rabindranath Tagore. Gandhi said, "Visitations like droughts, floods, earthquakes, and the like, though they seem to have only physical origins, are, for me, somehow connected with man's morals. Therefore, I instinctively felt that the earthquake was a visitation for the sin of untouchability."
Having said that, Gandhi "was transparency personified". While spirituality underpinned his every activity, he was rational first; "every ideology had to submit to the acid test of reason before being accepted".
How did Gandhi become spiritual, what were the influences in his life that shaped him and made him the colossus he later was to become? <b>One learns that his early influences were Shravana as a devoted son, Harishchandra as the ideal truthful human being. Kamath reveals, "Every fresh reading of their stories moved him to tears." Later Ruskin's Unto This Last and Leo Tolstoy all came to influence his mind. Then came the maid Rambha who instilled in young Gandhi the faith in the "Ramanama" (Rama's name) to ward off his fear of ghosts. Gandhi wrote, "The good seed sown in childhood was not sown in vain. I think it is due to the seed sown by that good woman Rambha that today Ramanama is an infallible remedy for me."</b>
As he grew up, Gandhi cultivated a distaste for conversion. He wrote, "Suppose a Christian came to me and said he was captivated by reading the Bhagavat and so wanted to declare himself a Hindu, I should say to him, 'No, what the Bhagavat offers, the Bible also offers. You have not made the attempt to find out. Make the attempt and be a good Christian'." To him, religion meant, "adhering to values, not to a brand name".
Kamath shares with us a story that brings out Gandhi's spiritual depth right from the time he was in Johannesburg and plague had broken out in the Indian ghetto. Then, the sick and dying were taken to a quarantined building where a heroic English nurse was tending to them. "One evening, at the height of the epidemic, she saw a small figure standing at the door." Get out, this is plague," shouted the nurse. But the man standing there was Gandhi whom the nurse recognised as a leader of the Indian community. He was not about to leave. He told the nurse, "It's alright; I've come to help you." And he went straight to the sick. One man was literally covered with vermin and the nurse again shouted a warning. She told Gandhi, "Leave him." But Gandhi would not. He merely told the nurse, "He is my brother." And he stayed all night long until relief came.
Finally, one <b>would have liked the English translation of the prayer, "Vaisnava jana to tene kahiye"</b>, printed on the back cover of the book followed by a note sharing with the non-Hindi reading reader what the prayer signified for Gandhi.
<!--QuoteEnd--><!--QuoteEEnd-->
Can our members provide the original and the translation please?