1. Before moving on, I seemed to have missed putting up the only statement in the above article by Aatish Taseer that I read that was sensible. (But Aatish didn't write it.)
The statement "a single generation of English education suffices to break the threads of tradition..." is not sufficient. It should have been phrased fully. The full version - and a heathen would have known to make the complaint - is more damning. (But I suppose it's expected that Coomaraswamy wouldn't know that.)
2. Oh dear.
haindavakeralam.com/HKPage.aspx?PageID=17836
I don't want to critique poor well-meaning Hindus from region X in India who want to learn the regional language of Y. Or that they wish to promote it.
BUT:
He's gone about it all wrong. And is about to alienate people - and has already caused some readers even in HK to worry.
I mean, if Tarun had said "We must promote many/all of our native languages in our universities, and offer benefits for those who learn/teach/promote it. We will inaugurate our support of Bharatiya languages with Tamizh - because this is another one of our ancient and cherised languages - and then we will hereafter similarly grow our efforts to include all our other native languages in similar fashion",
had Tarun said something like that, then I am sure Hindu readers would have cheered unanimously.
I.e. the focus should have been on BJP wanting to promote all our native languages (or at the very least all our officially recognised native languages), explaining they're "starting with Tamizh" since they're focusing on expanding to include that at present. Also, compliments can be made with sincerity without accidentally giving the impression that other native languages are excluded from an equal admiration.
For straightforward reasons, multi-lingualism can make people cleverer. Monolingualism tends to make people stupider. I think BJP and every Hindoo - from the layman onwards - ought to promote multilingualism - ideally starting with themselves, and starting with learning their own regional/mother languages and Skt, and can expand from there.
Also, multilingualism has a parallel in heathenisms, the way monolingualism has a parallel to the mono-moronisms. Monolingualism wipes out everything in its path, like monotheism.
Quote:'It is hard to realize,' Coomaraswamy writes in The Dance of Shiva, 'how completely the continuity of Indian life has been severed. A single generation of English education suffices to break the threads of tradition and to create a nondescript and superficial being deprived of all rootsââ¬âa sort of intellectual pariah who does not belong to the East or the West.'"
The statement "a single generation of English education suffices to break the threads of tradition..." is not sufficient. It should have been phrased fully. The full version - and a heathen would have known to make the complaint - is more damning. (But I suppose it's expected that Coomaraswamy wouldn't know that.)
2. Oh dear.
haindavakeralam.com/HKPage.aspx?PageID=17836
Quote:BJP MP from Uttarakhand seeks official status for Tamil
08/09/2013 03:45:19 [color="#0000FF"]articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2013-09-07/india/41854262_1_tarun-vijay-tamil-nadu-mps-rss-mouthpiece[/color]
CHENNAI: Tamil Nadu MPs in the Rajya Sabha were in for a surprise when Tarun Vijay, BJP MP representing Uttarakhand, demanded that the Centre declare Tamil the second official language of India.
"It is the arrogance and the feeling of a self-styled supremacy of some of my fellows in the north that we have not been able to fathom the real glory and importance of one of our greatest languages which is Tamil, its glory and influence can be felt across seven seas and caressing the highest peaks of the classical influence since ages and in all times," Vijay, a former editor of RSS mouthpiece 'Panchajanya', said in a special mention in the House on Thursday.
Vijay, one of the national spokespersons of the BJP and a former editor of RSS mouthpiece, Panchajanya, also said special scholarships, salary benefits and promotions be provided to government officials who gain a working knowledge of Tamil and demanded that Tamil chairs be established in all central universities.
Vijay, 52, said the Centre must start a scheme to propagate Tamil in all north Indian schools and colleges.
He said Tamil scholars had in the past visited Hindu holy places like Kedarnath and built links between the northern and southern parts of India. He buttressed the point about national integration with a mention of poet Subramania Bharati who, Vijay said, "wore a north Indian turban and became an icon of national unity and cultural renaissance".
He wondered if Tamil, "which has become the vehicle of a new Indian renaissance and cultural change", was ever given the respect and status it deserved. Vijay, who is learning Tamil, greets MPs from TN with a 'vanakkam'.
Expectedly, Vijay's unexpected eulogy for Tamil was welcomed by MPs from TN. CPI's D Raja said leaders living in north India acknowledging Tamil was very significant and they (MPs from TN) appreciated what Vijay said.
Vijay's promotion of Tamil is interesting as it also reflects a maturing of the approach towards languages in the country, especially within the Sangh Parivar. Outfits like Jan Sangh, the precursor of the BJP, and the RSS have been staunch proponents of making Hindi the sole national language. It was the aggressive championing of Hindi at the expense of regional languages that led to anti-Hindi protests and forced the Centre to continue with English as the second language for official purposes.
According to the Official Languages Act, 1963, Hindi is the official language of the Union of India with English as a second language for use of official purposes of the Union and for use in Parliament.
However, the Constitution allows states to adopt its own official languages. According to the 8th schedule of the Constitution, there are 22 official regional languages.
I don't want to critique poor well-meaning Hindus from region X in India who want to learn the regional language of Y. Or that they wish to promote it.
BUT:
He's gone about it all wrong. And is about to alienate people - and has already caused some readers even in HK to worry.
I mean, if Tarun had said "We must promote many/all of our native languages in our universities, and offer benefits for those who learn/teach/promote it. We will inaugurate our support of Bharatiya languages with Tamizh - because this is another one of our ancient and cherised languages - and then we will hereafter similarly grow our efforts to include all our other native languages in similar fashion",
had Tarun said something like that, then I am sure Hindu readers would have cheered unanimously.
I.e. the focus should have been on BJP wanting to promote all our native languages (or at the very least all our officially recognised native languages), explaining they're "starting with Tamizh" since they're focusing on expanding to include that at present. Also, compliments can be made with sincerity without accidentally giving the impression that other native languages are excluded from an equal admiration.
For straightforward reasons, multi-lingualism can make people cleverer. Monolingualism tends to make people stupider. I think BJP and every Hindoo - from the layman onwards - ought to promote multilingualism - ideally starting with themselves, and starting with learning their own regional/mother languages and Skt, and can expand from there.
Also, multilingualism has a parallel in heathenisms, the way monolingualism has a parallel to the mono-moronisms. Monolingualism wipes out everything in its path, like monotheism.
Death to traitors.