04-10-2006, 09:35 PM
<b>Reservation & Education : The inner story</b>
Mandal commission has revisited India in another name. The past is known to all of us. We all know the two brave son of nation set them on fire for the protest of it.
The GOI is set to make the law for the 49.5%(15%SC, 7.5%ST, 27%OBC) of reservation policy in education sector to all the levels. This also is the beginning of reservation in jobs in both public and private sector. There was some fee hike in IIMs and a lot of discussion was made on it. My this post will be a try to the inner angle of the story with different prospects.
<b>Angle 1</b>:The onle angle of the whole issue is to make social welfare engineering. In fact if there is a homogeneous representation of every class then there will be same representaion as per the reservation wagon wheel. The unprivileged has been denied of basic facility and discriminated for long times. Even in case of IIMs fee hike the poor and common student of the nation can not afford to pay the lacs fee of IIMs. So there should not be so high fee in these reputed institues.
<b>Angle2 </b> : The talent of the so called upper class students and people will go in vain. It leads to detoriation of talent pool and quality. Reservation if granted should be on the basis of the economical status. The flunked candiadates from the upper class feels frustrated and cheated. In IIMs fee hike the fee hike is geninune as it is required to keep the quality of the education. The fee is nothing to the handsome salary the IIM alumuni gets.
If both angles are studied without the pre concieved notions the all looks geniune on there parts.
<b><i>My Angle</i></b>: The money used in imparting education in IIM and IIT are much higher than the fee taken by the students. This infrastructure has been built by the money of the nation. This nation money has been the contribution or tax collection from the pooorest to the richest of the country. This leads to a moral boundage to these students. The private firms and company makes one to sign the bond to serve for certain tennure for money spend on the training. Should government takes steps to make use of these talents in there fields with legal bondings to work for in lieu of the well seduced education. I think the goverment has to be professional and strict on these issue. If students opt for MNC then the nation is in great loss and the whole sole of the money is wasted. There should be nothing free in this world. Already the scientific, defense science and manegerial skills are making us to lag behind the others. I think IITians and IIMians has to serve the nation than the MNC just for the sake of money. On the other hand I do not believe in the concept of reservation at all. Even if one select for the economic status for the reservation issues a new problem of dividing line and corruption. There is a just a need to provide equal oppourtunities by providing free and equal and mandatory education till 12. The equal and mandatory education will lead to development of vision among the students to look from open minded approah for the benifit of all and the nation. The students are the ultimate power for the nation and has to be guided to a correct path. Remember the freedom struggle, JP Movement, China's democaratic demand by students it shows the importance of us students and youth. In recent times the youth of France has compelled the French govt to take back anti-youth acts.
There is a need of coherence in thoughts among different masses of youth. The clashes and differences in thoughts is because of the different backgrounds and short term goals. The question of who is right and who is wrong cannot be answered in comprehensive manner. There is a need of talented work force in govt programmes and organization. Who will keep the flags of Nuclear development, Satellite programme, Green revolution etc. The MNC are here for the cost cutting and the dolar turn to 45-46 times in India. This is the reason why we are getting the huge amount in MNC and IT world. If we start with allegation both the sides will be found dirty. Lets do not run away from the problem and the RAVANA of our mind. If an electrical engineer from IIT opts for the IT markety the country looses one skilled and potential resource for power management of the country. The electrical grid system in the nation is the unique and the best of its kind. I do not blame much on the commom students as they have limited oppourtunities and choices. <b>"The more powerful you are the more responsible you should be."</b>.
The message is simple if you want to serve the nation the nation should serve you with priveliges otherwise be ready to pay as per the market and business rules.
In hope of your warm responses.
Regards,
Amol Deep <!--emo&:ind--><img src='style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/india.gif' border='0' style='vertical-align:middle' alt='india.gif' /><!--endemo-->
Mandal commission has revisited India in another name. The past is known to all of us. We all know the two brave son of nation set them on fire for the protest of it.
The GOI is set to make the law for the 49.5%(15%SC, 7.5%ST, 27%OBC) of reservation policy in education sector to all the levels. This also is the beginning of reservation in jobs in both public and private sector. There was some fee hike in IIMs and a lot of discussion was made on it. My this post will be a try to the inner angle of the story with different prospects.
<b>Angle 1</b>:The onle angle of the whole issue is to make social welfare engineering. In fact if there is a homogeneous representation of every class then there will be same representaion as per the reservation wagon wheel. The unprivileged has been denied of basic facility and discriminated for long times. Even in case of IIMs fee hike the poor and common student of the nation can not afford to pay the lacs fee of IIMs. So there should not be so high fee in these reputed institues.
<b>Angle2 </b> : The talent of the so called upper class students and people will go in vain. It leads to detoriation of talent pool and quality. Reservation if granted should be on the basis of the economical status. The flunked candiadates from the upper class feels frustrated and cheated. In IIMs fee hike the fee hike is geninune as it is required to keep the quality of the education. The fee is nothing to the handsome salary the IIM alumuni gets.
If both angles are studied without the pre concieved notions the all looks geniune on there parts.
<b><i>My Angle</i></b>: The money used in imparting education in IIM and IIT are much higher than the fee taken by the students. This infrastructure has been built by the money of the nation. This nation money has been the contribution or tax collection from the pooorest to the richest of the country. This leads to a moral boundage to these students. The private firms and company makes one to sign the bond to serve for certain tennure for money spend on the training. Should government takes steps to make use of these talents in there fields with legal bondings to work for in lieu of the well seduced education. I think the goverment has to be professional and strict on these issue. If students opt for MNC then the nation is in great loss and the whole sole of the money is wasted. There should be nothing free in this world. Already the scientific, defense science and manegerial skills are making us to lag behind the others. I think IITians and IIMians has to serve the nation than the MNC just for the sake of money. On the other hand I do not believe in the concept of reservation at all. Even if one select for the economic status for the reservation issues a new problem of dividing line and corruption. There is a just a need to provide equal oppourtunities by providing free and equal and mandatory education till 12. The equal and mandatory education will lead to development of vision among the students to look from open minded approah for the benifit of all and the nation. The students are the ultimate power for the nation and has to be guided to a correct path. Remember the freedom struggle, JP Movement, China's democaratic demand by students it shows the importance of us students and youth. In recent times the youth of France has compelled the French govt to take back anti-youth acts.
There is a need of coherence in thoughts among different masses of youth. The clashes and differences in thoughts is because of the different backgrounds and short term goals. The question of who is right and who is wrong cannot be answered in comprehensive manner. There is a need of talented work force in govt programmes and organization. Who will keep the flags of Nuclear development, Satellite programme, Green revolution etc. The MNC are here for the cost cutting and the dolar turn to 45-46 times in India. This is the reason why we are getting the huge amount in MNC and IT world. If we start with allegation both the sides will be found dirty. Lets do not run away from the problem and the RAVANA of our mind. If an electrical engineer from IIT opts for the IT markety the country looses one skilled and potential resource for power management of the country. The electrical grid system in the nation is the unique and the best of its kind. I do not blame much on the commom students as they have limited oppourtunities and choices. <b>"The more powerful you are the more responsible you should be."</b>.
The message is simple if you want to serve the nation the nation should serve you with priveliges otherwise be ready to pay as per the market and business rules.
In hope of your warm responses.
Regards,
Amol Deep <!--emo&:ind--><img src='style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/india.gif' border='0' style='vertical-align:middle' alt='india.gif' /><!--endemo-->