06-20-2007, 06:06 PM
Itâs not about her - SHOBHAA DE
http://www.indianexpress.com/story/34025.html
Can we please appraise Pratibha Patil without this stifling regional tokenism and gender symbolism
The presidential election is beginning to come out of my ears. Like a lot of people, Iâve reached a stage when I feel like screaming, âJust get on with it â but spare us the tamasha.â The latest embarrassment to derail the anointment of Pratibha Patil involves her comments on the purdah. If the lady doesnât know her history, one wonders whether her knowledge of geography is stronger. Would she be able to defend our borders as the commander-in-chief of the Armed Forces? Someone aptly described her nomination as a âmonumental jokeâ being played on the nation by Sonia Gandhi. Itâs likely to turn into a joke that backfires if the lady does in fact waltz into the Rashtrapati Bhavan. Though, going by the lack of enthusiasm even within Congress party ranks (and her purdah faux pas), she may just make it easier for the pro-Kalam or pro-Shekhawat lobby to rush past her in the final run-up.
The real tragedy in this debacle is not Pratibha Patil per se â poor thing, she is once again playing a familiar role of handmaiden to the Gandhis. It is the abject denigration of the post itself. From the sublime to the ridiculous, to the downright shabby, the pathetic wheeling and dealing, horse trading and lobbying that have scarred this election, this is nothing short of an insult to the high office. Kahan Radhakrishnan aur kahan Pratibhatai! Besides, nobody cares, nor is anyone convinced with the overnight âimage makeoverâ attempts to position and sell her as the ultimate Bharatiya Naari â a shining symbol of womenâs empowerment. What a bogus claim. And as phony and suspect as the nomination itself.
Letâs face it, Pratibha Patil has been pulled out of her mothballed existence and shoved into the spotlight for one reason alone â she is the most accommodating and pliant of the uninspiring bunch that make up the list. She will ensure the safety of the seats of her political masters if it ever comes to that. Lacklustre? Of course. But loyal and obedient â prized attributes given the sensitivity (and fragility) of the numbers game. What if...? Yes, indeed, what if a situation does arise when a crucial presidential vote would decide the fate of the government? Will Pratibhtai have the credentials to take an independent, non-partisan stand? Will she dare to snub Sonia Gandhi and rise above party politics? Put the country first?
It is meaningless to argue the lady deserves a shot at it, or to be asked why we are writing her off without giving her a fair chance. My point is: can we afford such a luxury? If we are being asked to extend our generosity and âgive her a chanceâ, why not be still more large-hearted and give Bhairon Singh Shekhawat the same chance?
Sorry, this isnât about either petty nit-picking or witch-hunting. The truth is, most Indians donât know who Pratibha Patil is. And what they have come to know, post-nomination, has left them cold. I wish I could get excited over a former table tennis champion or someone who organised kho-kho and kabbadi matches during her college days. There is nothing impressive or remarkable about any of her touted âachievementsâ. But the problem is, any voiced criticism against the lady is seen as a strike against women.
Come on, letâs leave phony sisterhood and solidarity out of this. It angers me each time a feminist angle is introduced into the debate. A true feminist will never endorse the wrong woman, for that itself goes against the tenets of empowerment. Unfortunately, gender has been superimposed in this case, and an attempt is being made to damn any woman who does not automatically sing hosannahs to Pratibhatai. I resent this sort of manipulation. Call me anti-women, if you wish, I feel like telling these newly-minted champions of stree shakti, but I will not join the chorus singing Taiâs praises.
Where was she all these years? Has anyone heard a peep out of her during numerous debates dealing with atrocities against women? What has she done that is pro-women? Has she raised her voice even once? Not that I know of. So, can we please leave gender out of this, for it communicates the wrong message. Patilâs accident of birth as a female is being flaunted as a badge of honour. God help us. By that definition, any and every woman of India qualifies for the prestigious post.
Letâs be upfront about this. Pratibha Patil simply does not have what it takes to be the President of India. As for all that rubbish regarding her simplicity, spare me the baloney. As if a khadi sari is the ultimate or only description of simplicity! Khadi happens to be one of the most high maintenance fabrics in the country. Ladies who make khadi their big statement invest a lot of money in it. Soniaâs saris are homespun too. But are they cheap? Half the women in India wouldnât be able to afford these designer khadi one-offs. So, letâs not delude ourselves. Forget about her lack of a Page 3 presence, thatâs the least of her problems. Can she make it to Page 1, without most of her countrymen asking, âWhoâs she?â Itâs time we grew up and stopped playing immature games of tokenism, symbolism, etc. The important thing is to rise above any and every kind of ism, from feminism to regionalism. Just because I am a woman and a Maharashtrian, should I support Pratibhatai? No way.
If Pratibha Patil does make it to Rashtrapati Bhavan, how will it benefit the women of India? Will it lead to fewer thrashings, beatings, torture, murders? Give me a break. This 73-year-old lady deserves to spend her retirement years with more dignity than as a puppet of her long-term patrons. Zail Singh had his jhaddoo. What will Pratibhatai use? Her pallav?
http://www.indianexpress.com/story/34025.html
Can we please appraise Pratibha Patil without this stifling regional tokenism and gender symbolism
The presidential election is beginning to come out of my ears. Like a lot of people, Iâve reached a stage when I feel like screaming, âJust get on with it â but spare us the tamasha.â The latest embarrassment to derail the anointment of Pratibha Patil involves her comments on the purdah. If the lady doesnât know her history, one wonders whether her knowledge of geography is stronger. Would she be able to defend our borders as the commander-in-chief of the Armed Forces? Someone aptly described her nomination as a âmonumental jokeâ being played on the nation by Sonia Gandhi. Itâs likely to turn into a joke that backfires if the lady does in fact waltz into the Rashtrapati Bhavan. Though, going by the lack of enthusiasm even within Congress party ranks (and her purdah faux pas), she may just make it easier for the pro-Kalam or pro-Shekhawat lobby to rush past her in the final run-up.
The real tragedy in this debacle is not Pratibha Patil per se â poor thing, she is once again playing a familiar role of handmaiden to the Gandhis. It is the abject denigration of the post itself. From the sublime to the ridiculous, to the downright shabby, the pathetic wheeling and dealing, horse trading and lobbying that have scarred this election, this is nothing short of an insult to the high office. Kahan Radhakrishnan aur kahan Pratibhatai! Besides, nobody cares, nor is anyone convinced with the overnight âimage makeoverâ attempts to position and sell her as the ultimate Bharatiya Naari â a shining symbol of womenâs empowerment. What a bogus claim. And as phony and suspect as the nomination itself.
Letâs face it, Pratibha Patil has been pulled out of her mothballed existence and shoved into the spotlight for one reason alone â she is the most accommodating and pliant of the uninspiring bunch that make up the list. She will ensure the safety of the seats of her political masters if it ever comes to that. Lacklustre? Of course. But loyal and obedient â prized attributes given the sensitivity (and fragility) of the numbers game. What if...? Yes, indeed, what if a situation does arise when a crucial presidential vote would decide the fate of the government? Will Pratibhtai have the credentials to take an independent, non-partisan stand? Will she dare to snub Sonia Gandhi and rise above party politics? Put the country first?
It is meaningless to argue the lady deserves a shot at it, or to be asked why we are writing her off without giving her a fair chance. My point is: can we afford such a luxury? If we are being asked to extend our generosity and âgive her a chanceâ, why not be still more large-hearted and give Bhairon Singh Shekhawat the same chance?
Sorry, this isnât about either petty nit-picking or witch-hunting. The truth is, most Indians donât know who Pratibha Patil is. And what they have come to know, post-nomination, has left them cold. I wish I could get excited over a former table tennis champion or someone who organised kho-kho and kabbadi matches during her college days. There is nothing impressive or remarkable about any of her touted âachievementsâ. But the problem is, any voiced criticism against the lady is seen as a strike against women.
Come on, letâs leave phony sisterhood and solidarity out of this. It angers me each time a feminist angle is introduced into the debate. A true feminist will never endorse the wrong woman, for that itself goes against the tenets of empowerment. Unfortunately, gender has been superimposed in this case, and an attempt is being made to damn any woman who does not automatically sing hosannahs to Pratibhatai. I resent this sort of manipulation. Call me anti-women, if you wish, I feel like telling these newly-minted champions of stree shakti, but I will not join the chorus singing Taiâs praises.
Where was she all these years? Has anyone heard a peep out of her during numerous debates dealing with atrocities against women? What has she done that is pro-women? Has she raised her voice even once? Not that I know of. So, can we please leave gender out of this, for it communicates the wrong message. Patilâs accident of birth as a female is being flaunted as a badge of honour. God help us. By that definition, any and every woman of India qualifies for the prestigious post.
Letâs be upfront about this. Pratibha Patil simply does not have what it takes to be the President of India. As for all that rubbish regarding her simplicity, spare me the baloney. As if a khadi sari is the ultimate or only description of simplicity! Khadi happens to be one of the most high maintenance fabrics in the country. Ladies who make khadi their big statement invest a lot of money in it. Soniaâs saris are homespun too. But are they cheap? Half the women in India wouldnât be able to afford these designer khadi one-offs. So, letâs not delude ourselves. Forget about her lack of a Page 3 presence, thatâs the least of her problems. Can she make it to Page 1, without most of her countrymen asking, âWhoâs she?â Itâs time we grew up and stopped playing immature games of tokenism, symbolism, etc. The important thing is to rise above any and every kind of ism, from feminism to regionalism. Just because I am a woman and a Maharashtrian, should I support Pratibhatai? No way.
If Pratibha Patil does make it to Rashtrapati Bhavan, how will it benefit the women of India? Will it lead to fewer thrashings, beatings, torture, murders? Give me a break. This 73-year-old lady deserves to spend her retirement years with more dignity than as a puppet of her long-term patrons. Zail Singh had his jhaddoo. What will Pratibhatai use? Her pallav?