07-03-2004, 06:52 PM
Kaushal > Done - Topic has been merged.
Thanks Garu
> All good things are associated with the Gora chamda - virtue, goodness,ability, education, leadership.
<!--emo&--><img src='style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/smile.gif' border='0' style='vertical-align:middle' alt='smile.gif' /><!--endemo-->) . I can hear Umrao crooning "Gori Gori o banki Chori Kabhi mera ghar ayaa Karo" ( A Goldie Oldir from KK )
Sunder > It would be good to hear in this thread if the action is LEGALLY & CONSTITUTIONALLY possible, valid, and what could be the reason a president had to succumb to the pressures of a minority government.
I am no lawyer, but still, there have been such change-overs in past.
President of India had to follow the dictat of GOI. There is no issue of "succumbing" , it was not as if "Article 356" was being forced by President of India on behalf of GOI.
It will be naive of BJP/NDA or anybody politically aware to not expect this. This is politics and nit a simple flow-chart. And here BJP showed there inaptitude with handling the Medium and telling to Media that BJP ( LKA & Venkaiah ) has "instructed" to these "Governers" not to resign. Now "Governor" being non-partisan cannot be *instructed* by a party by logic.
In short after ABV manali musing goal , this is another self goal, had they not spoken abt "instruction" , BJPcld have reaped the ladoo of "Moral High ground".
If I am wrong , pls comment.
Thanks Garu
> All good things are associated with the Gora chamda - virtue, goodness,ability, education, leadership.
<!--emo&--><img src='style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/smile.gif' border='0' style='vertical-align:middle' alt='smile.gif' /><!--endemo-->) . I can hear Umrao crooning "Gori Gori o banki Chori Kabhi mera ghar ayaa Karo" ( A Goldie Oldir from KK )
Sunder > It would be good to hear in this thread if the action is LEGALLY & CONSTITUTIONALLY possible, valid, and what could be the reason a president had to succumb to the pressures of a minority government.
I am no lawyer, but still, there have been such change-overs in past.
President of India had to follow the dictat of GOI. There is no issue of "succumbing" , it was not as if "Article 356" was being forced by President of India on behalf of GOI.
It will be naive of BJP/NDA or anybody politically aware to not expect this. This is politics and nit a simple flow-chart. And here BJP showed there inaptitude with handling the Medium and telling to Media that BJP ( LKA & Venkaiah ) has "instructed" to these "Governers" not to resign. Now "Governor" being non-partisan cannot be *instructed* by a party by logic.
In short after ABV manali musing goal , this is another self goal, had they not spoken abt "instruction" , BJPcld have reaped the ladoo of "Moral High ground".
If I am wrong , pls comment.