Chandramoulee, are you sure? Sirdesai has repeatedly written on Offstumped. RS could as easily be using the handle Sirdesai as someone else.
Here is another comment:
Sirdesai
October 13th, 2008 at 4:58 pm
Prannoy a Christian is an old story. You are a fool if you didnât know that. Actually it happened when his brother married Mary. And I told you guys many a times - Bengali CPIM leaders are not Christians. They are actually upper caste Brahmin or Kayasth. I heard from Mazumdar that 85% of their ministers/MLAs are from upper caste. Secularism comes naturally to a Bengali who has crossed plus 2 level. Itâs imbibed into their school system. Thatâs why I recruit mainly Bongs since I donât need to train them on my channelâs vision and ideals. And for the numbnuts contemplating about my belief - Iâm a liberal secular peace-loving agnostic Hindu.
****On the other hand, if you are sure this Sirdesai is not RS, I will take your word for it..I do not know the history of Offstumped as well as you do..you have been there longer than me.
Here is another comment:
Sirdesai
October 13th, 2008 at 4:58 pm
Prannoy a Christian is an old story. You are a fool if you didnât know that. Actually it happened when his brother married Mary. And I told you guys many a times - Bengali CPIM leaders are not Christians. They are actually upper caste Brahmin or Kayasth. I heard from Mazumdar that 85% of their ministers/MLAs are from upper caste. Secularism comes naturally to a Bengali who has crossed plus 2 level. Itâs imbibed into their school system. Thatâs why I recruit mainly Bongs since I donât need to train them on my channelâs vision and ideals. And for the numbnuts contemplating about my belief - Iâm a liberal secular peace-loving agnostic Hindu.
****On the other hand, if you are sure this Sirdesai is not RS, I will take your word for it..I do not know the history of Offstumped as well as you do..you have been there longer than me.

