<!--QuoteBegin-->QUOTE<!--QuoteEBegin-->Clearly, the picture is more complex, and will only be resolved when new SNPs resolve the phylogeny of this widespread haplogroup."
<!--QuoteEnd--><!--QuoteEEnd-->
Joker needs to understand that the displacement issue has been resolved at the level of r1a1 and r1a1a (which had coincident expansions). Further resolution will only be local and will not impact this finding. There is a convergence of data showing r1b in Asia (E Persia, Zagros/Turkmen/S. Caspian), R1a1 in Afpak, and R2 in Bengal. r1a1 expansion was nothing less than a pressure cooker going off in Afpak.
<!--QuoteEnd--><!--QuoteEEnd-->
Joker needs to understand that the displacement issue has been resolved at the level of r1a1 and r1a1a (which had coincident expansions). Further resolution will only be local and will not impact this finding. There is a convergence of data showing r1b in Asia (E Persia, Zagros/Turkmen/S. Caspian), R1a1 in Afpak, and R2 in Bengal. r1a1 expansion was nothing less than a pressure cooker going off in Afpak.