11-19-2009, 02:18 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-19-2009, 02:20 PM by HareKrishna.)
[quote=dhu,Nov 19 2009, 12:58 PM]
[quote]Indians appear to display the higher diversity both in haplogroups 3 and 9 - even if a pooled sample of eastern and southern European populations was considered. If we were to use the same arithmetic and logic (sensu haplogroup 9 is Neolithic) to give an interpretation ofspecially when the other candidate line (R ) in Europe is from a wholly different, distinctly Asiatic, and phylogenetically later 'process'.
It is quite a scandal that all the "experts" managed to switch IJ and R entry into europe. People are realizing this now.
e northern route. R naturally expanded in the direction of least resistance.
[right][snapback]102670[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Yet the biggest diversity for J is around Kurdistan.
Lets not confuse date of mutation whit the date of expansion.
It remain to establish how much J is neolithic and how much in pre-neolithic.
Maybe J in Europe is pre-neolithic also;we wonder why not alll of Europe become J2 and E3b if the farmer migration from the Turkey was so important.Why J2 stop to Balkan and Italy despite the fact that farming spread up to Denmark?
Beside ,J2 is very new ,comparative whit other y-chromosomes.
[quote]Indians appear to display the higher diversity both in haplogroups 3 and 9 - even if a pooled sample of eastern and southern European populations was considered. If we were to use the same arithmetic and logic (sensu haplogroup 9 is Neolithic) to give an interpretation ofspecially when the other candidate line (R ) in Europe is from a wholly different, distinctly Asiatic, and phylogenetically later 'process'.
It is quite a scandal that all the "experts" managed to switch IJ and R entry into europe. People are realizing this now.
e northern route. R naturally expanded in the direction of least resistance.
[right][snapback]102670[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Yet the biggest diversity for J is around Kurdistan.
Lets not confuse date of mutation whit the date of expansion.
It remain to establish how much J is neolithic and how much in pre-neolithic.
Maybe J in Europe is pre-neolithic also;we wonder why not alll of Europe become J2 and E3b if the farmer migration from the Turkey was so important.Why J2 stop to Balkan and Italy despite the fact that farming spread up to Denmark?
Beside ,J2 is very new ,comparative whit other y-chromosomes.