10-04-2010, 04:30 AM
@G-Swamy
In 1969, Hamid Dalwai, a believing muslim, who was yet a nationalist and in the good books of the RSS
wrote that every muslim complaint is based on that they are a non-ruling minority
They hate Congress, Socialists, Communists and Jan Sangh, because they were all Hindu controlled
He even spoke to kashmiri muslims and their gripe was India was not a muslim majority country
He even dissected Ghaffar Khan, that his trajectory was downward, from being Frontier Gandhi, due to muslim cultural factors
Hamid Dalwai, blamed muslim culture- He did not dig deeper that this muslim culture is due to koran and hadiths
-
http://hvk.org/Publications/wit.html
WIT AND WISDOM OF HAMID DALWAI'
A SECULAR MUSLIM
Excerpts from his Book "Muslim Politics In Secular India"
1.4 - It is difficult for a Hindu to visualize, except by a special effort of reason and the imagination, a mind that is almost totally lacking in the conception of the individual and derives the significance of human life solely from the individual's membership of a collectivity. (pg. 12)
3.9 - Indian Muslims still regard themselves as Pakistanis, and they believe that their emancipation has been ensured by the creation of Pakistan. (pg-50)
4.1 - All Muslim leaders unanimously complain that injustice is done to Muslims in India. However, they have a strange definition of injustice.....
One of the methods of ensuring justice is to claim that Pakistani infiltrators in Assam are not Pakistani at all. A second method is to demand the granting of Indian citizenship to those Pakistanis who are illegal residents of Bihar, West Bengal and some other states of India. A third method is to oppose family planning. (pg.53)
4.6 - Jinnah was not fighting Savarkar and Golwalkar. He never mentioned their communalism. He never mentioned their communalism. Jinnah accused Gandhi of being a Hindu communalist, refusing to concede his demands. He criticised Nehru in the same way. Similarly, when Muslim leaders hold communalists responsible for the partition, they want to suggest that it was Gandhi and Nehru who were 'Hindu communalists'.
4.8 - Independence, according to the Muslims, is synonymous with all power being concentrated in the hands of the Muslim community. (pg-66)
4.9 - They claim that the Hindu majority in India treats them with injustice. They fail to realize that their definition of Islam is twisted and strange, for these leaders believe that the greatest injustice to Indian Muslims is the simple fact that there is a majority of Hindus in this country. (pg.69)
In 1969, Hamid Dalwai, a believing muslim, who was yet a nationalist and in the good books of the RSS
wrote that every muslim complaint is based on that they are a non-ruling minority
They hate Congress, Socialists, Communists and Jan Sangh, because they were all Hindu controlled
He even spoke to kashmiri muslims and their gripe was India was not a muslim majority country
He even dissected Ghaffar Khan, that his trajectory was downward, from being Frontier Gandhi, due to muslim cultural factors
Hamid Dalwai, blamed muslim culture- He did not dig deeper that this muslim culture is due to koran and hadiths
-
http://hvk.org/Publications/wit.html
WIT AND WISDOM OF HAMID DALWAI'
A SECULAR MUSLIM
Excerpts from his Book "Muslim Politics In Secular India"
1.4 - It is difficult for a Hindu to visualize, except by a special effort of reason and the imagination, a mind that is almost totally lacking in the conception of the individual and derives the significance of human life solely from the individual's membership of a collectivity. (pg. 12)
3.9 - Indian Muslims still regard themselves as Pakistanis, and they believe that their emancipation has been ensured by the creation of Pakistan. (pg-50)
4.1 - All Muslim leaders unanimously complain that injustice is done to Muslims in India. However, they have a strange definition of injustice.....
One of the methods of ensuring justice is to claim that Pakistani infiltrators in Assam are not Pakistani at all. A second method is to demand the granting of Indian citizenship to those Pakistanis who are illegal residents of Bihar, West Bengal and some other states of India. A third method is to oppose family planning. (pg.53)
4.6 - Jinnah was not fighting Savarkar and Golwalkar. He never mentioned their communalism. He never mentioned their communalism. Jinnah accused Gandhi of being a Hindu communalist, refusing to concede his demands. He criticised Nehru in the same way. Similarly, when Muslim leaders hold communalists responsible for the partition, they want to suggest that it was Gandhi and Nehru who were 'Hindu communalists'.
4.8 - Independence, according to the Muslims, is synonymous with all power being concentrated in the hands of the Muslim community. (pg-66)
4.9 - They claim that the Hindu majority in India treats them with injustice. They fail to realize that their definition of Islam is twisted and strange, for these leaders believe that the greatest injustice to Indian Muslims is the simple fact that there is a majority of Hindus in this country. (pg.69)