09-30-2012, 06:45 AM
(This post was last modified: 09-30-2012, 06:46 AM by G.Subramaniam.)
epw
Conclusions
What explains this upsurge in Muslim
representation at the grass roots of
political life in UP? While this requires
much greater study, it surely points to
a growing autonomy of the Muslim
communities vis-ÃÂ -vis political parties.
But the question then arises as to why
this increased Muslim representation in
urban local governments does not get
replicated in assembly and parliamentary
elections? One part of an answer
may be that urban areas have dense
Muslim residential clusters while most
assembly and parliamentary constituencies
have a mix of rural and urban
areas, making it diffi cult for Muslim
candidates to get an edge on the basis of
community support.
However, in Muslim-dominant ULBs,
an unwelcome aspect is that there are
hardly any seats reserved for dalits. In
a very large number of cases, just one
seat is reserved for a dalit woman in the
nagar palikas and the urban panchayats.
It is still not clear as to what is the cause of
this lack of reserved seats, whether it is
because of the migration of dalits to non-
Muslim areas, or some other cause. This
makes these ULBs virtually non-representative
of dalits. Even among the Other
Backward Classes (OBCs) category, such
areas are electing only Muslim OBCs.
While adequate representation of Muslims
is welcome, their massive over-representation
in ULBs, that too at the cost
of dalits and non-Muslim OBCs, is a matter
of concern and can lead to a range of
diffi cult and dangerous political situations
in the future.
Conclusions
What explains this upsurge in Muslim
representation at the grass roots of
political life in UP? While this requires
much greater study, it surely points to
a growing autonomy of the Muslim
communities vis-ÃÂ -vis political parties.
But the question then arises as to why
this increased Muslim representation in
urban local governments does not get
replicated in assembly and parliamentary
elections? One part of an answer
may be that urban areas have dense
Muslim residential clusters while most
assembly and parliamentary constituencies
have a mix of rural and urban
areas, making it diffi cult for Muslim
candidates to get an edge on the basis of
community support.
However, in Muslim-dominant ULBs,
an unwelcome aspect is that there are
hardly any seats reserved for dalits. In
a very large number of cases, just one
seat is reserved for a dalit woman in the
nagar palikas and the urban panchayats.
It is still not clear as to what is the cause of
this lack of reserved seats, whether it is
because of the migration of dalits to non-
Muslim areas, or some other cause. This
makes these ULBs virtually non-representative
of dalits. Even among the Other
Backward Classes (OBCs) category, such
areas are electing only Muslim OBCs.
While adequate representation of Muslims
is welcome, their massive over-representation
in ULBs, that too at the cost
of dalits and non-Muslim OBCs, is a matter
of concern and can lead to a range of
diffi cult and dangerous political situations
in the future.