02-25-2012, 07:49 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-25-2012, 08:43 AM by G.Subramaniam.)
Errors in PISA 2009 Indian scores - part 2
-----
My hypothesis is that the downshift in the mean and top-end scores is due to deliberate gerrymandering to lower the PISA score. The low PISA score would in turn raise a clamor for more govt money to go to Public schools and Public school teacher salaries. This is in line with leftist NGOs. This gerrymandering could easily be done by a low to mid-level official who had infiltrated the Indian PISA team
--
https://mypisa.acer.edu.au/images/mypisa...tional.pdf
Has the complete PISA report
--
Table A.2: Population coverage indices
This shows that in most countries 1% of the schools were sampled for PISA
However, the TN, HP data is so bad, they dont have a clue on what the sampling ratio is
Table A3,
TN had 143 schools appearing for PISA
HP had 66 schools appearing for PISA
Whereas in Costa Rica, 180 schools appeared for PISA
Table A4
TN PISA had 3210 students
HP PISA had 1616 students
Costa Rica PISA had 4578 students
The Population of TN is 65 million, and the Population of HP is 7 million and the population of Costa Rica is 4 million
PISA has no idea, what fraction of the total population of TN and HP were sampled
My first alert is the very small sampling in TN and HP
-----
My hypothesis is that the downshift in the mean and top-end scores is due to deliberate gerrymandering to lower the PISA score. The low PISA score would in turn raise a clamor for more govt money to go to Public schools and Public school teacher salaries. This is in line with leftist NGOs. This gerrymandering could easily be done by a low to mid-level official who had infiltrated the Indian PISA team
--
https://mypisa.acer.edu.au/images/mypisa...tional.pdf
Has the complete PISA report
--
Table A.2: Population coverage indices
This shows that in most countries 1% of the schools were sampled for PISA
However, the TN, HP data is so bad, they dont have a clue on what the sampling ratio is
Table A3,
TN had 143 schools appearing for PISA
HP had 66 schools appearing for PISA
Whereas in Costa Rica, 180 schools appeared for PISA
Table A4
TN PISA had 3210 students
HP PISA had 1616 students
Costa Rica PISA had 4578 students
The Population of TN is 65 million, and the Population of HP is 7 million and the population of Costa Rica is 4 million
PISA has no idea, what fraction of the total population of TN and HP were sampled
My first alert is the very small sampling in TN and HP