01-16-2007, 11:48 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-16-2007, 11:49 PM by Bharatvarsh.)
<!--QuoteBegin-->QUOTE<!--QuoteEBegin-->Nasrinâs remarks trigger another row
Mohammed Wajihuddin | TNN
Mumbai: Fugitive Bangladeshi writer Taslima Nasrin has created a fresh controversy with her remarks about purdah, Prophet Mohammed, his wives and his companions in her article for a newsmagazine. Nasrinâs call to Muslim women to disobey the Quranic injunctions and burn the burqa has outraged Muslim organisations that have demanded that the Kolkata-based writer be expelled from India.
Nasrinâs piece titled âLetâs Burn the Burqaâ has upset a section of Muslims, and some ulemas have planned a meeting on Monday after which the course of action will be decided.
âTotal belief in Quran and Hadith (words of the Prophet) is part of our imaan. We just cannot keep quiet over these blasphemous statements about the holy Prophet and his wives,ââ said Sayeed Noorie of Raza Academy, an organisation of Sunni Muslims.
Nasrin quotes some instances from the Prophetâs life which the Muslims find out-of-context and objectionable. Nasrin writes: âProphet Mohammedâs wife Ayesha was very beautiful. His friends were often found staring at her with fascination. This clearly upset the Prophet. So the Quran has an Ayat that says, âOh friends of the prophet or holy men, never go to your friendâs house without an invitation. And if you do go, donât go and ask anything of their wivesâ.ââ Nasrin further elaborates: âItâs to resist the greedy eyes of friends, disciples or male guests that the purdah system came into being.ââ
Islamic scholar Asghar Ali Engineer rubbished Nasrinâs interpretation of the Quranic verse: âShe gives a wrong interpretation. Quran never uses the word purdah. It only asks women to dress properly. Itâs a blatant lie to suggest that the Prophetâs companions or disciples were fascinated with his wife Ayesha.ââ
Engineer, who has written extensively on womenâs status in Islam, also clarified that the question of whether women should cover their faces while in public is debatable. Muslim theologians are divided over the purdah of face since the Quran doesnât talk about it. Nasrin has no right to pass comments on something which she has not studied properly, says Engineer.
Some questioned the prudence of the Indian government for sheltering Nasrin who has been expelled from Bangladesh after she wrote Lajja (Shame), a novel depicting anti-minority atrocities in Bangladesh in the
aftermath of Babri demolition in 1992. âShe has become a symbol of communal disharmony. She is a threat to our peace. The government should cancel her visa immediately,ââsaid Maulana Zaheer Abbas Rizvi of Shia Muslim Personal Law Board.
Some Muslim women activists have rejected Nasrinâs call, saying the Quran provides them enough rights to lead a respectful life. âHijab or purdah is for our security. Whoâs Taslima to tell us to burn the burqa?ââ asked advocate Neelofar Akhtar who works for the uplift of women. Urdu dailies too have condemned Nasrin. On Sunday, two Mumbai-based Urdu dailies, Rashtriya Sahara and Urdu Times, front-paged the news. <!--QuoteEnd--><!--QuoteEEnd-->
By that token that b@st@rd Engineer should stop churning out his ill informed trash defaming Hindus.
Mohammed Wajihuddin | TNN
Mumbai: Fugitive Bangladeshi writer Taslima Nasrin has created a fresh controversy with her remarks about purdah, Prophet Mohammed, his wives and his companions in her article for a newsmagazine. Nasrinâs call to Muslim women to disobey the Quranic injunctions and burn the burqa has outraged Muslim organisations that have demanded that the Kolkata-based writer be expelled from India.
Nasrinâs piece titled âLetâs Burn the Burqaâ has upset a section of Muslims, and some ulemas have planned a meeting on Monday after which the course of action will be decided.
âTotal belief in Quran and Hadith (words of the Prophet) is part of our imaan. We just cannot keep quiet over these blasphemous statements about the holy Prophet and his wives,ââ said Sayeed Noorie of Raza Academy, an organisation of Sunni Muslims.
Nasrin quotes some instances from the Prophetâs life which the Muslims find out-of-context and objectionable. Nasrin writes: âProphet Mohammedâs wife Ayesha was very beautiful. His friends were often found staring at her with fascination. This clearly upset the Prophet. So the Quran has an Ayat that says, âOh friends of the prophet or holy men, never go to your friendâs house without an invitation. And if you do go, donât go and ask anything of their wivesâ.ââ Nasrin further elaborates: âItâs to resist the greedy eyes of friends, disciples or male guests that the purdah system came into being.ââ
Islamic scholar Asghar Ali Engineer rubbished Nasrinâs interpretation of the Quranic verse: âShe gives a wrong interpretation. Quran never uses the word purdah. It only asks women to dress properly. Itâs a blatant lie to suggest that the Prophetâs companions or disciples were fascinated with his wife Ayesha.ââ
Engineer, who has written extensively on womenâs status in Islam, also clarified that the question of whether women should cover their faces while in public is debatable. Muslim theologians are divided over the purdah of face since the Quran doesnât talk about it. Nasrin has no right to pass comments on something which she has not studied properly, says Engineer.
Some questioned the prudence of the Indian government for sheltering Nasrin who has been expelled from Bangladesh after she wrote Lajja (Shame), a novel depicting anti-minority atrocities in Bangladesh in the
aftermath of Babri demolition in 1992. âShe has become a symbol of communal disharmony. She is a threat to our peace. The government should cancel her visa immediately,ââsaid Maulana Zaheer Abbas Rizvi of Shia Muslim Personal Law Board.
Some Muslim women activists have rejected Nasrinâs call, saying the Quran provides them enough rights to lead a respectful life. âHijab or purdah is for our security. Whoâs Taslima to tell us to burn the burqa?ââ asked advocate Neelofar Akhtar who works for the uplift of women. Urdu dailies too have condemned Nasrin. On Sunday, two Mumbai-based Urdu dailies, Rashtriya Sahara and Urdu Times, front-paged the news. <!--QuoteEnd--><!--QuoteEEnd-->
By that token that b@st@rd Engineer should stop churning out his ill informed trash defaming Hindus.