What DNA Says About Aryan Invasion Theory -2

[G.Subramaniam]

[quote name='dhu' date='09 March 2010 - 10:54 PM' timestamp='1268154963' post='105001']

It was discussed on IF long time back. A very recent expansion time for R is a nightmare for gora. And this is precisely what the data is showing.

[/quote]



Dhu, a few days ago, the Y-DNA of King Tut was found to be R1B

R1B seems to start in Iran and go south of the caspian sea on both sides of the mediterranean

Many Berbers have R1B too

The basques are R1B too

Meaning the original R1B language was non-IE



On wiki, the earliest dates of R1A is 14000 BC in India

and 9000BC for Poland

Assuming at 9000BC, the slavs were in Af-pak and migrated with IE-Satem

and at 5000BC, went into R1B areas as an IE speaking elite

the satem-centum switch is likely to have happened at this point



Satem = R1A, Centum = R1B



For example the sentence

The wolf mother



is Vrkasya Matam in Sanskrit and Vilkos Matina in Lithuanian

both R1A, Satem



Whereas in Greek and Latin, both R1B, it is Lupum Mater



I think Centum languages are like Malayalam

A large amount of Sanskrit words but ultimately rooted in Tamil



Thats why the excercise to find proto-IE is a fools errand



It may be easier to find Proto-Satem