05-19-2006, 10:35 PM
No comment
<!--emo&:roll--><img src='style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/ROTFL.gif' border='0' style='vertical-align:middle' alt='ROTFL.gif' /><!--endemo-->
<!--QuoteBegin-->QUOTE<!--QuoteEBegin-->Dear Prof Kancha,
   Greetings
I am writing this mail to you with great hope.
Sir, it was your book ' Why I am not a Hindu' that i read first when I joined JNU for MA in August 2001. Since then I have lost my peace of mind, career of my parents choice and have debt of about 30 thousand on my head (due to short lived venture INSIGHT). So to repay this debt, after my father's death, I have taken up a job. Still your book never let me to choose 'lucrative' jobs but be satisfied with a job that is part of our movement.
I am not the only one whom you have so 'adversly' affected. Atleast I know two more cases where students like me 'suffered' because they got affected by your writings and thoughts.
1. One of my friend was thrown out of CSCS banglore because he wanted to work on your writings but his teachers thought that you are not a scholar but mere pamphleteer. But friend of mine is pretty confirmed that you are scholar of first grade. So now being thrown out of the institue he is roaming here and there to get admission.
2. Second friend of mine was told by his guide to remove your name from his English PHD synopsis bibiliography. Again the reason was that this guide of his considered you a mere pamphleteer. This friend of mine was little smart as he quietly listened to his guide's diatribe against you and then had heartly laugh while narrating the story to us. We felt so happy that your name is terror to Indian Accademia. Still this friend of mine gets nightmares whether he will be able to get his Phd or not.
Sir, like this you and your writings might have 'badly' affected many of our youngsters through out the length and breadth of the country. They might have become restless and eager to fight for our cause, against brahminism, against caste system with out caring about their lives, families and careers.
But they cant do much. They might be getting frustrated, sad and dejected.
They are unable to use their full potential, talents and channelise energies due to lack of any worthy platform, role models, leaders.
Our creativity is yet to be tapped.
In my humble opinion the reason is that
Our intellectualls do tell the path and goal but are not there when we initiate moving towards that goal.
They tell us to organise but forget to tell how to organise.
They tell us to fight but forget to tell how to fight
So all our youths' time is spent by repeating '"organise & Fight'
The same thing is happening now also. More than month had gone since media onslaught on our dignity and blackmail of doctors. Yet there is no reply from our side except chantings of "organise and fight", "organise and fight".
None of us are able to even resort to our democratic right to protest.
But this time Sir, some of us will not sit quitely.
We are definetly going to organise and fight.
But this time you have to pay the price of making us restless and suffer so much that we cant even read newspapers and watch TVs these days unlike millions of our community people doing this daily.
Sir, we want you to be present with us when we start our fight. We want you to be there with us on streets. We want you to be there in educational institutations where we will visit and mobilise our students. We want you to lead us.
*THE SAME IS TRUE FOR ALL OUR OTHER INTELLECTUALS - Prof GOPAL GURU, VTR, PROF THORAT, DR. VIVEK KUMAR, DR. TULSI RAM, DR RAMAIAH, DR SURYAKANT WAGHMARE, DR NANDU RAM, DR. WANKHEDE, MUDRARAKSHA, MR RAJENDRA YADAVA, MADAM THORAT, RUTH MONARMA, BAMA, RAJNI TILAK, CHANDRABHAN PRASAD, AND MANY OTHERS.*
**
*Then there are many intellectuals like SHARMILA REGE, SUSIE THARU, UMA
CHAKARVARTI, PROF SHIVA SHANKARÂ who are also culprits of creating
restlessness among youths,*
So now you all cannot disown us. There is no other alternative for all of you except to come with us on streets and lead us.
BECAUSE YOU ALL HAVE MADE YOUNGSTERS RESTLESS, ANGRY AND EAGER TO FIGHT BACK.
many many regards to all
xxx kumar
JNU
<!--QuoteEnd--><!--QuoteEEnd-->
<!--emo&:roll--><img src='style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/ROTFL.gif' border='0' style='vertical-align:middle' alt='ROTFL.gif' /><!--endemo-->
<!--emo&:roll--><img src='style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/ROTFL.gif' border='0' style='vertical-align:middle' alt='ROTFL.gif' /><!--endemo-->
<!--QuoteBegin-->QUOTE<!--QuoteEBegin-->Dear Prof Kancha,
   Greetings
I am writing this mail to you with great hope.
Sir, it was your book ' Why I am not a Hindu' that i read first when I joined JNU for MA in August 2001. Since then I have lost my peace of mind, career of my parents choice and have debt of about 30 thousand on my head (due to short lived venture INSIGHT). So to repay this debt, after my father's death, I have taken up a job. Still your book never let me to choose 'lucrative' jobs but be satisfied with a job that is part of our movement.
I am not the only one whom you have so 'adversly' affected. Atleast I know two more cases where students like me 'suffered' because they got affected by your writings and thoughts.
1. One of my friend was thrown out of CSCS banglore because he wanted to work on your writings but his teachers thought that you are not a scholar but mere pamphleteer. But friend of mine is pretty confirmed that you are scholar of first grade. So now being thrown out of the institue he is roaming here and there to get admission.
2. Second friend of mine was told by his guide to remove your name from his English PHD synopsis bibiliography. Again the reason was that this guide of his considered you a mere pamphleteer. This friend of mine was little smart as he quietly listened to his guide's diatribe against you and then had heartly laugh while narrating the story to us. We felt so happy that your name is terror to Indian Accademia. Still this friend of mine gets nightmares whether he will be able to get his Phd or not.
Sir, like this you and your writings might have 'badly' affected many of our youngsters through out the length and breadth of the country. They might have become restless and eager to fight for our cause, against brahminism, against caste system with out caring about their lives, families and careers.
But they cant do much. They might be getting frustrated, sad and dejected.
They are unable to use their full potential, talents and channelise energies due to lack of any worthy platform, role models, leaders.
Our creativity is yet to be tapped.
In my humble opinion the reason is that
Our intellectualls do tell the path and goal but are not there when we initiate moving towards that goal.
They tell us to organise but forget to tell how to organise.
They tell us to fight but forget to tell how to fight
So all our youths' time is spent by repeating '"organise & Fight'
The same thing is happening now also. More than month had gone since media onslaught on our dignity and blackmail of doctors. Yet there is no reply from our side except chantings of "organise and fight", "organise and fight".
None of us are able to even resort to our democratic right to protest.
But this time Sir, some of us will not sit quitely.
We are definetly going to organise and fight.
But this time you have to pay the price of making us restless and suffer so much that we cant even read newspapers and watch TVs these days unlike millions of our community people doing this daily.
Sir, we want you to be present with us when we start our fight. We want you to be there with us on streets. We want you to be there in educational institutations where we will visit and mobilise our students. We want you to lead us.
*THE SAME IS TRUE FOR ALL OUR OTHER INTELLECTUALS - Prof GOPAL GURU, VTR, PROF THORAT, DR. VIVEK KUMAR, DR. TULSI RAM, DR RAMAIAH, DR SURYAKANT WAGHMARE, DR NANDU RAM, DR. WANKHEDE, MUDRARAKSHA, MR RAJENDRA YADAVA, MADAM THORAT, RUTH MONARMA, BAMA, RAJNI TILAK, CHANDRABHAN PRASAD, AND MANY OTHERS.*
**
*Then there are many intellectuals like SHARMILA REGE, SUSIE THARU, UMA
CHAKARVARTI, PROF SHIVA SHANKARÂ who are also culprits of creating
restlessness among youths,*
So now you all cannot disown us. There is no other alternative for all of you except to come with us on streets and lead us.
BECAUSE YOU ALL HAVE MADE YOUNGSTERS RESTLESS, ANGRY AND EAGER TO FIGHT BACK.
many many regards to all
xxx kumar
JNU
<!--QuoteEnd--><!--QuoteEEnd-->
<!--emo&:roll--><img src='style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/ROTFL.gif' border='0' style='vertical-align:middle' alt='ROTFL.gif' /><!--endemo-->